Starting a full RFP (Request for Proposal) / tender process can be an overwhelming prospect. Various elements such as which suppliers to invite, what questions to ask and how to evaluate their responses present their own challenges.
Gray Dawes is here to help you better your experience by running through each element of the RFP process to enable you to partner with a Travel Management Company (TMC) that is ideal for your business.
Where to begin
Business travel touches many people across a business. As such we would recommend meeting your internal subject matter experts to understand how the programme affects them and how the TMC can bring more value to their teams:
- Key bookers
- Key travellers
- A member of HR
- A member of the Finance team
- A member of the IT team
Their experience and knowledge of departmental processes (e.g. invoicing and payment for Finance) will be key when building question sets that bring palpable responses.
Who to invite
Creating your own shortlist can be done easily if you know where to look and the best places to start would be:
- The profiles of the UK’s top 50 TMCs: https://www.businesstravelnewseurope.com/Europes-leading-TMCs
- Members of the British Travel Association (BTA): https://www.thebta.org.uk/bta-members
- Institute of Travel Management: https://www.itm.org.uk/
If you hold a good relationship with a TMC and have reviewed their standing in the UK market, it would be worth including them on your shortlist.
What to ask
Within an RFP, structure is everything. We would suggest building a list of chapters of the key areas for your travel management programme and working from there. For example:
- Executive Summary
- Online Booking Tool – Content available, functionality, mobile app compatible
- Service Delivery Team – Size of team, location, experience, SLAs
- Account Management – How will they drive performance, experience
- Reporting – Dashboard availability, live reporting capability, frequency of reports
- Implementation – Time frames, key personnel
- Added Value – Cost savings, additional services, tangible and intangible benefits
- Commercials – Compliant and premium models
Take the information gained from your internal review and reach out to your key bookers, their insight into the day to day operations will enable you to gather a list of salient questions to really tailor the RFP to your business.
Setting timelines
As part of your early engagement with your shortlist of suppliers you should inform them when the RFP will be released, giving them the opportunity to research your business, plan the necessary internal meeting to discuss the bid and build it within their prospect pipeline.
Within your RFP documents you should dedicate a section that details all of the key dates within a table so that it is clear and all in one place for the reader. For example:
| Activity | Date |
| Release of RFP documents to supplier | 8th April |
| Clarification questions from supplier | 15th April |
| Responses to clarification questions | 22nd April |
| Submission of supplier responses | 6th May |
| Supplier shortlisted | 11th May |
| Supplier presentations | 18th May |
| Successful supplier announced | 1st June |
| Implementation | 6th July |
| Go Live | 3rd August |
Evaluation matrix and weightings
Comparing suppliers is a challenging exercise, there will be numerous responses written and presented in different ways.
One method to take the strain from your evaluation is to create a weightings matrix which can be shared with the suppliers within the RFP document. A weightings matrix simply breaks down what is important to your business and the areas to focus on for the supplier. From a client side it will present a ‘scoring card’ for the evaluation process.
Scoring:
0-5%: Supplier meets some of the requested criteria
6-14%: Supplier compliant
15-20%: Supplier displays excellent understanding of our requirements
| Section | Weighting |
| Executive Summary | 30% |
| Cultural alignment | 10% |
| Service | 10% |
| Technology | 10% |
| Content | 10% |
| Commercials | 20% |
| Added Value | 10% |
Presentation stage
Once a bid has been submitted and evaluated you are ready to conduct the presentation stage. This can be carried out at your office, the supplier’s proposed operations centre or in this current climate over WebEx / Zoom.
It would be beneficial to share an agenda of topics that you want to be covered – this provides a ‘yard stick’ for you to evaluate the suppliers. If there is no agenda, your ability to score the presentations will become near impossible.
And the winner is….
Now time to share some good news! Once you have informed the TMC they have been successful they will take the reigns for you and begin the transition and implementation process until the go live date.
And they booked travel happily ever after….
DO YOU NEED A LITTLE MORE GUIDANCE OR ADVICE?
WE’RE HAPPY TO HELP
Related Articles
What is the True Value of a TMC?
A recent article from The Business Travel Magazine claims that Travel Management Companies (TMCs) like Gray Dawes are struggling to provide value for their clients. However, at Gray Dawes, we respectfully and heartily disagree… After all, not all TMCs are created equally. Tarring everyone with the same brush only serves to devalue the brilliant work and innovative thinking that organisations such as ours bring to the industry. In this article, we take a deeper look at the “Value Proposition” piece from the Business Travel Magazine and demonstrate how we are genuinely doing things differently.
How the Paris Olympics 2024 will Impact Business Travel (And What You Can Do About It)
The Olympic Games are heading to Paris in July. Over 10,000 athletes will be throwing, swimming, running, cycling, and more for the chance to grab a gold medal and write themselves into the annals of Olympic history. But with an estimated 15 million visitors planning to head to the event according to the Paris je t’aime tourist office, travelling to and within Europe for work will almost certainly be affected. In this article, we take a look at how the Paris Olympics 2024 might impact business travel and offer our expert tips and advice to help you keep your trip on course.
Flight100: Testing The Limits of Sustainable Aviation Fuel (SAF)
The use and effectiveness of Sustainable Aviation Fuel (SAF) remains one of the hottest topics in business travel. Back in 28 November 2023, Virgin Atlantic successfully operated Flight100 – the world’s first commercial SAF flight from London to New York. In this article we extract the key findings of the ground-breaking feat as outlined in the Executive Summary produced by the team behind it all.